Families Of San Bernardino Attack Victims Side With Government In Apple Encryption Fight
Mourners comfort one another at a makeshift memorial for the victims of the attack in San Bernardino, Calif.
Jae C. Hong / AP
Six family members of victims in the San Bernardino terrorist attack are asking a court to rule in favor of the FBI in the government's legal battle with Apple over access to an encrypted iPhone.
"They are individuals who own and use smartphones and other mobile technology on a daily basis," the brief said. "They are also victims of this terribly tragedy and have a unique interest in the United States' investigation of the iPhone in its custody."
Stephen Larson, a California attorney representing families who lost loved ones in the San Bernardino terrorist attack, filed the friend of the court brief on Thursday.
Last month, Larson told BuzzFeed News he was asked by U.S. Attorney Eileen Decker and San Bernardino County District Attorney Mike Ramos to write an amicus brief supporting the government's position. A former federal judge and prosecutor, Larson grew up in the area, and seeks to offer judge Sheri Pym the perspective of some of the attack's victims — families who are looking for answers.
Carolyn Kaster / AP
Greg Clayborn lost his daughter, Sierra Clayborn. James Godoy lost his wife, Aurora Godoy. Tina Meins lost her father, Damian Meins. Mark Sandefur lost his son, Larry Daniel Eugene Kaufman. Robert Velasco lost his daughter, Yvette Velasco. Hal Houser is the husband of Beth Houser, who attended the party, but survived.
The brief goes on to note that while much of the debate has focused on potential global implications of Apple's actions, the government is seeking to investigate a specific act of terrorism.
"Ultimately, this is a situation where no stone can be left unturned," the brief said.
Judge Pym recently ordered Apple to help the FBI break into an encrypted iPhone belonging to one of the San Bernardino terrorists, who, along with his wife, killed 14 people last year. The iPhone remains locked and inaccessible. But the FBI suspects the device may hold valuable information — pointing federal investigators to possible co-conspirators.
The FBI has asked Apple to create new software that would bypass and disable several security features on the iPhone. Apple, however, has argued that by creating new, FBI-sanctioned software, the security of every iPhone and many of its consumers would be jeopardized.
The victims' brief adds that the case is ultimately about one phone, which belonged to the shooter's employer, San Bernardino County. The county has given permission for the FBI to have access to the phone.
"After stripping Apple's hyperbole about the evils of government overreach, this case's facts are nearly identical to the owner of a computer operation system losing the password for the system and calling technical support to get the password changed or reinstalling the operating system," the brief said. "While Microsoft and Apple routinely help computer owners with this all-too-common situation, Apple refuses to do the same in a case with national-security implications."
via BuzzFeed - Tech http://ift.tt/1Y7rLn4
Put the internet to work for you.
No comments: